Why Being on the Internet Feels Cringe

That familiar feeling is what we call cringe, and it is not actually caused by a real audience laughing at you. It is simply your brain reacting to the perceived threat that they might be judging you behind a screen. You are experiencing embarrassment for yourself, in the same social-pain system that lights up when you feel it for someone else. The internet makes this feeling incredibly intense because your audience is both permanently recorded and entirely invisible.
Your brain reacts to the threat of being judged, not just to proof that you were judged. Perfection usually reads as highly rehearsed, but keeping the awkward moments, makes your audience trust you more. That is the beautiful mess effect, showing a flaw can make you seem more, not less, trustworthy (Bruk et al., 2018). Real and unpolished content usually feels safer to the viewer than a rigid corporate script. In a fascinating study on vicarious embarrassment, participants watched scenarios where either a friend or a stranger faced a threat to their social standing. The researchers found that activity in the brain areas involved in sharing another person's social pain increased significantly when the threat happened to someone close to them (Muller-Pinzler, Rademacher, Paulus, and Krach, 2016). When you feel close to someone, even parasocially online, watching them try too hard makes your own body react like your personal reputation is on the line.

If you are a creator or a brand trying to show up online, your first step is to completely stop trying to be cringe-proof. This uncomfortable feeling is just a social signal that you care about how you come across, and that underlying empathy is exactly what makes you relatable to your buyers. Perfection usually reads as highly rehearsed, but keeping the awkward moments (like a first take or a genuine laugh at yourself) makes your audience trust you instantly. Real and unpolished content always feels much safer to the viewer than a rigid corporate script.
To quiet that embarrassment, you need to deliberately make the audience smaller in your head when you hit publish. You are not posting for the whole world; you are only posting for the people who already get your message and need your unique value. The cringe will never go away completely because your brain is just doing its job to protect you from social threats. However, you do not have to let it stop you from connecting with your ideal community. Tell me about one post you almost deleted but are so glad you kept in the comments below.
References
Bruk, A., Scholl, S. G., & Bless, H. (2018). Beautiful mess effect: Self-other differences in evaluation of showing vulnerability. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 115(2), 192-205. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspa0000120
Muller-Pinzler, L., Rademacher, L., Paulus, F. M., & Krach, S. (2016). When your friends make you cringe: Social closeness modulates vicarious embarrassment-related neural activity. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 11(3), 466-475. https://doi.org/10.1093/scan/nsv130

- Kristina Bozanich - I am a fractional CMO, media producer, Congressional Record Honoree, and LGBTQ+ Advocate. To see more updates, follow on social media or sign up for email subscriptions.




Comments